What does a dresser have to do with divorce? Plenty, if it comes in a flat-pack and requires a couple to assemble it together at home.
Of all the things that can spark major marital tiffs — e.g. fair division of household labor, debt, lack of toilet seat etiquette — home improvement projects are high on the list. But there’s one DIY job in particular that contributes to marital discord.
According to a new survey out of Great Britain, ex-couples overwhelmingly cited the task of assembling flat-pack furniture as the project that caused the most arguments. (Please refer to IKEA exhibits a) the NORDLI floating headboard bed with drawers; b) the PAX wardrobe with sliding doors, and c) the HEMNES dresser.)
Spending hours interpreting instructions (40 pages for the HEMNES), organizing parts (more than 150 to put together the PAX wardrobe) and searching for missing pieces caused more than three quarters (78%) of couples to bicker.
HerMoney CEO Jean Chatzky can relate. “My husband and I tried to put together a white IKEA pedestal table at the beginning of our marriage, started sniping at each other,” she says. “A couple of hours later — with pieces scattered everywhere — we decided to hire someone to do it for us.” Even though it cost almost as much for assembly as it did for the piece itself, is any amount too high of a price to pay for keeping the marital peace?
The projects that contribute to broken homes
Assembling flat-pack furniture was just one of the home improvement projects that were most likely to drive couples to divorce court. To find out exactly where renovations caused relationships to sour, MyJobQuote.co.uk (a U.K.-based matchmaking service for homeowners and home repair tradespeople) interviewed roughly 2,000 ex-couples about their fixer-upper fights.
More than 70% of ex-couples who called it splitsville said they experienced discord over decor decisions.
Not surprisingly, couples cited money as one factor that led to fights: 81% of respondents said exceeding the home improvement budget was their biggest issue. However, it’s the detail work that drove a wedge between formerly happy twosomes.
- Two in five arguments were sparked by unfinished projects. (Specifically, exterior painting, plastering, floor sanding/refinishing.)
- Jobs requiring precision, like plumbing and tiling, were also cited as a major source of relationship stress by 58% and 52% of ex-couples, respectively.
- Woe is the partner who expresses an alternative opinion about interior design. More than 70% of those who called it splitsville said they experienced discord over decor decisions.
|Home improvements that caused the most arguments||Percentage of ex-couples that argued|
|Assembling flat-pack furniture||78%|
|Unfinished exterior painting||67%|
|Plumbing kitchen sink||58%|
|Unfinished floor sanding||54%|
|Tiling bathroom floor||52%|
|Unfinished electrical wiring||24%|
Don’t let paint chips color your partnership
Just like fights about money often aren’t about money at all, dickering over design can sometimes be just another outlet for expressing relationship distress.
Psychologist Lee Chambers was asked by the study’s authors to comment on the findings and why assembling flat-pack furniture was such a hot-button project. “It’s often a test of control. One side of a relationship is likely to drive the project forward, and this can lead to a feeling of helplessness on the other side,” Chambers said.
Decor decisions — like financial decisions — are informed by each partner’s design taste, which, Chambers says, is “cultivated by their childhood, culture and experiences.” The hundreds of choices involved in home renovation projects require each party to compromise at some point.
Or try the solution that Jean and her husband found: Their mantra is, “We don’t assemble.” (Strangely, Chatzky says, not being married may be the key to doing this together. Almost a decade after their divorce, she and her first husband found themselves in their daughter’s college apartment tasked with — you guessed it — putting together a flat packed dresser, and it actually went pretty smoothly, she says.)
Here are three things to help maintain your happily-ever-after during a home improvement project:
- Decide what’s most important to each of you: Before you draw up plans and create your dream kitchen vision board, decide which parts of the renovation matter most to each of you individually. Separately make lists of your “must haves” ranked in order of importance and compare notes. Maybe you have your heart set on picking the backsplash tile and your partner is really choosy about appliances. Decide ahead of time how you’ll settle stand-offs where your opinions differ. (Base the decision on cost? A coin toss? Let a decorator make the call?)
- Set a reasonable timetable for the project: Next to budget issues, procrastination was the second most commonly issue (cited by 77% of respondents) that led to arguments. Also the length of time projects took was a trigger for 45% of ex-couples. The solution: Give yourself some padding, no matter what the project. If you’re working with a contractor, ask how long it took to complete a similar job for past clients. And if you’re putting together the PAX wardrobe from IKEA, plan on it taking at least four hours, according to Any Assembly, a moving and furniture assembly company. With any project, keep yourselves motivated to finish by coming up with rewards for reaching certain project milestones.
- Approach it as partners, not adversaries: Whether it’s assembling a dining table or replacing siding, home improvement projects are meant to enhance the nest you share. Acknowledge upfront that there will be challenges like delays and cost overages and unforeseen surprises like funky wiring or rotted floor joists. But at least you’re not going through it alone! Decide ahead of time how you’ll handle them. As with merging finances as a new couple, keep the focus on the rewards you reap as a twosome. Take a few tips from these couples who tackled money-centric goals together and came out better on the other side of the challenge.
All things home improvement on HerMoney.com:
- 5 Most Profitable Home Improvements You Should Make Before Selling Your Home
- Paying for a Home Reno Without Upfront Cash: 5 Financing Options Explained
- How to Decorate Like Your Favorite TV Character on a Budget
Own your money, own your life. Subscribe today to get the latest money news and tips!