Protect Insurance

Ask Jean: “I’m Getting My Children A Puppy. Should I Get Pet Insurance?”

HerMoney Staff  |  October 14, 2026

A reader who plans to get her children a puppy for Christmas asks whether pet insurance is a good idea...or a waste of money.
Four Leaf Federal Credit Union — Money Like a Woman Willow — The Wealth Accelerator for women and their families InvestingFixx from HerMoney — get your first month free

Twice a week, our CEO and resident money guru Jean Chatzky tackles your burning questions in the HerMoney newsletter. We’ve pulled some of the best to feature on our website — and this one made the cut! Got a question for Jean? Send it her way right here.

Q: Today’s question comes from Lizzy. She writes: “I am getting my children a new puppy for Christmas. Does pet insurance make sense, or is it a waste of money?”

A: How fun! That is, once you get past the potty training part.

In short, pet insurance is a good idea. A recent survey shows pet costs – vet bills, grooming, the works – are up 44% since 2019. For many owners (myself included), insurance can make furry friends more affordable. (As a pup, my dog Norman had an incident when he stepped on a carpet that had recently been cleaned, then licked his paws and ended up in the ER. Insurance saved us thousands then and has continued to do so through his bouts with allergies, anxiety, and many ear infections.)

Depending on the type of policy, coverage can include accidents, illnesses, hereditary conditions, dental disease, and behavioral issues.

The best way to think about pet insurance is a lot like human health insurance. When buying pet insurance, you purchase the policy hoping that you won’t have to use it. But with it, you have the peace of mind knowing that you can safely say “yes” to necessary and increasingly expensive health care if an accident does occur or your pet becomes sick.

As with any insurance plan, you’ll want the most coverage at the most affordable price point. Essentially, you’re looking for a provider that will offer coverage specific to both your pet’s needs and your own financial needs. “If you can pay for the yearly visits and the vaccinations, but you think if my pet gets cancer, I can’t do a $3,000 vet bill, then that is the type of coverage you are looking for,” says Melissa Gutierrez, SVP and General Manager of Pets Best.

Most insurers offer a variety of plans — you’ll just need to do your homework and compare each one. Typically, the standard plans offered by most pet insurance providers include accident and illness, accident-only, and wellness, which can also help defray costs for annual check-ups.

MORE ON HERMONEY:

SUBSCRIBE: Looking for more financial insights delivered right to your inbox? Make this thing official with a free HerMoney subscription today!

Editor’s note: We maintain a strict editorial policy and a judgment-free zone for our community, and we also strive to remain transparent in everything we do. Posts may contain references and links to products from our partners. Learn more about how we make money.

Next Article: